Articles
How we decide a book is in print
Updated November 22, 2026
In print, on this site, is a dated fact about a specific ISBN. It is not a vibe, and it is not “I saw a copy once.”
The check
Marvel’s bookstore distributor is Penguin Random House. DC’s bookstore editions are on the same site. For every book in the first catalog we opened the product page and recorded only what that page stated.
- In print. The page offers the book and the on-sale date is in the past. On the pages we fetched, that looked like a paperback price, a “Published on” date, and an Add to Cart control. The edition’s
inPrintflag is true only in this case. - Forthcoming. The page gives a future date and a preorder. Fall of the Mutants and Wonder Woman: Judgment in Infinity! are both January 19, 2027. They are not in print yet.
- Out of print. We will use this only when a publisher or distributor page says the edition is out of print. The first catalog has no out-of-print rows. We would rather have a hole than a guess.
Every record stores lastVerified. For this launch, that date is November 22, 2026. A book can leave the distributor’s catalog after that day. The badge on the page is only as fresh as the date next to it.
What we will not use as proof
A Wikipedia table, a two-year-old solicitation, or a used-bookstore listing can help you find a book to check. They do not set the ISBN, the page count, or the status.
The Batman DC Finest volume is the example we keep on the wall. DC Connect #50, in July 2024, solicited Year One & Two at 592 pages. The published Penguin Random House record is 632 pages, $39.99, ISBN 9781779528353, on sale November 5, 2024. The solicitation is linked from the edition because it shows the plan. The page count in the record is the published one.
The same thing happens to titles. DC’s February 22, 2024 announcement called the first Superman Finest volume The Coming of Superman. The book Penguin Random House sells is The First Superhero, and the contents line matches what was announced: Action Comics #1-25, Superman #1-5, New York World’s Fair #1. We file it under the published title.
Fields we leave empty
If the product page does not state a contents line, issuesCollected is omitted. The Long Halloween Compact, Watchmen, Kingdom Come, and V for Vendetta are in that category. You can know what story it is. You cannot get an issue list from us that the source did not print.
If the page does not state a trim size, we do not copy the trim from a sibling in the same line. Several Epic Collections have no trim in the record for that reason, even though others say 6-5/8 x 10-3/16.
Canadian list price is the same rule. The pages we used show US dollars. No CAD field is filled in this seed.
New printings
An Epic Collection that comes back usually comes back with a new ISBN. The Goblin’s Last Stand in this catalog is “New Printing 2,” ISBN 9781302967796. An older printing of that subtitle is not automatically in print because this one is. Record the printing name when the product page uses it.
The editorial checklist for adding a book is in CONTENT_GUIDE.md. The short version: open the distributor page, write down what it says, date the visit, and leave the rest blank.
Questions
What counts as in print?
A current Penguin Random House product page that offers the paperback or hardcover, with an on-sale date that has already arrived. The check date is stored on the edition.
Why are there no out-of-print books in the first catalog?
We only mark a book out of print when a publisher or distributor page says so. Absence from this catalog is not that evidence.
Why is there no Canadian price?
The US Penguin Random House pages we used publish a USD list price. We did not find a CAD list price on those pages, so the field is omitted.